• March 17, 2025
  • 17 5785, Adar
  • פרשת ויקהל

The WebYeshiva Blog

By Rabbi Johnny Solomon When it comes to the Omer, Parshat Emor states that we should count 50 days (see Vayikra 23:16). In contrast, later on in the Torah we are told to count seven weeks (see Devarim 16:9). As Abaye explains (in Chagigah 17b), from here we learn that ‘there is a commandment to count days, and there is a commandment to count weeks’ – from which we learn that counting days is different from counting weeks, and that when it comes to Sefirat HaOmer we need to count both. But how should we relate differently to the counting of the days and the weeks of the Omer? Rabbi Meir Horowitz of Dzikov (1819-1877) explains in his ‘Imrei Noam’ commentary that the concept of ‘day’ refers to intellectual clarity (because the day is bright and clear), while ‘week’ refers to our values which give us a life of meaning and our character traits which thereby express our values. Put simply, day refers to מוח (mind), while week refers to מידות (character traits). Understood this way, the process of counting both the days and the weeks of the Omer teaches us about the importance of both nurturing our thoughts and perfecting our values and character traits to be worthy to receive the Torah which we receive on Shavuot. Shabbat Shalom!
Parshat Hashavua
Respect for the elderly By Rabbi Johnny Solomon Among the various mitzvot listed in Parshat Kedoshim is the requirement to stand up and show respect for the elderly (see Vayikra 19:32). Significantly, this verse concludes with the words, “and you should revere your God; I am the Lord” (ibid.) which prompts our Sages (see Kiddushin 32b) to wonder what additional point is being made here? They answer by explaining that this additional phrase refers to those who wish to close their eyes to avoid seeing an elder approaching them and thereby avoid the need to revere them. Instead, as Rashi explains, such an individual ‘should have feared the Creator who knows your thoughts [and who is aware of how you are] seeking strategies to become exempt from his commandments.’

In halacha

In terms of halacha, the Shulchan Aruch (Yoreh Deah 244:3) firmly rules that, ‘it is forbidden to close one’s eyes prior to coming within four amot [of an elderly person] in order to avoid the need to stand up for them [and show respect towards them]’. However, as Rabbi Daniel Z. Feldman explains in his recently published ‘Letter and Spirit: Evasion, Avoidance and Workarounds in the Halakhic System’ (Maggid, 2024), this law serves as an example of how we shouldn’t avoid or evade the performance of mitzvot. At the same time, as Rabbi Feldman explains throughout his book, there have been times when certain workarounds have been justified to avoid or evade the fullfilment of certain laws. Given this, why – specifically – are our Sages so insistent that we not avoid this particular law?

Increasing love of Torah

Rabbi Feldman answers by quoting Rabbi Yosef Shaul Nathanson (Responsa Shoel U’Meishiv, telita’ah I No. 120) who explains that ‘this commandment is specifically centered on increasing the love one has for the Torah and its scholars, and accordingly, actively embracing the opportunity is a part of its directive’ (Letter and Spirit p. 12). Overall, what this teaches us is that while we should strive to fulfil all the commandments, though some may be side-stepped in certain situations, some – which go to the core of our values and beliefs – may not. Shabbat Shalom!
Parshat Hashavua
Mind and Body By Rabbi Johnny Solomon In his commentary to Parshat Tazria, the Netziv (Haemek Davar on Vayikra 13:44) explains that ‘the reasons for contracting Tzora’at on the body are not the same as those associated with Tzora’at on the head. Tzora’at on the body arises from the sins of desire (i.e. lust) that leads the body astray, while Tzora’at on the head comes for sins of the mind (i.e. heretical ideas).’ Having stated this distinction between body and head, the Netziv then explains that the reason why the Torah makes specific reference to cases of Tzora’at both on the back and the front of the head (see Vayikra 13:40-43) is because people come to heretical conclusions because of two very different reasons. One is in response to confused philosophical analysis which then leads to errors in belief. According to the Netziv, this occurs in the front of the brain. However, a further way is through the absence of philosophical analysis which leads a person to develop their own faulty ideas about God and Judaism which, according to the Netziv, occurs in the back of the brain. Having made this point, the Netziv explains that because the Torah first speaks about Tzora’at on the back of the head, it comes to teach us that ‘errors in emuna [stemming from confusion] are much more common, and much worse, than mistakes resulting from erroneous intellectual analysis.’ As #theVirtualRabbi, I often find that clients who experience a spiritual crisis do so when their beliefs about God do not align with their personal life experience. However, all too often it becomes clear that their beliefs about God are very confused due to the fact that they have had little serious exposure to Jewish philosophy. And so the way I support these clients is by teaching them Jewish sources which address Jewish belief which thereby help them resolve some of the confusing beliefs which they have been holding onto. To find out more, and to book a free spiritual coaching discovery call, visit https://webyeshiva.org/about-virtual-rabbi.
Parshat Hashavua
Total Inner Withdrawal By Rabbi Johnny Solomon Beyond the inauguration of the Mishkan, Parshat Shmini also describes the sudden death of Aharon’s two sons. Yet notwithstanding this incredible loss, Aharon is instructed not to adopt the classic mourning rituals of growing his hair or tearing his clothes. As Rav Soloveitchik explains in his essay ‘Catharsis’, ‘Aharon belonged to no one, not even to himself… Therefore he was not even free to give himself over to the grief precipitated by the loss of his two sons.’ Of course, this was an incredibly tough ask of Aharon during such a difficult moment in his life. Yet the point which Rav Soloveitchik is making here is that there are times when we all need to practically or emotionally restrain ourselves for the sake of adhering to religious rules. As he writes: ‘Once man enters the service of God, be it as high-priest, be it as an ordinary humble person… he is subject to the divine call for total inner withdrawal. Here the halacha intervenes frequently in the most intimate and personal phases of our lives and makes demands upon us which often impress the uninitiated as overly rigid and formal.’ Overall, what this means is that keeping halacha can be hard and that the observance of halacha can often require significant self-sacrifice. This is why, as we are told in Brachot 32b, so many of the core foundations of Jewish living - such as Torah study, good deeds, prayer and even earning a livelihood - require chizuk (encouragement), because even those already committed to Jewish practice can sometimes find things hard. As you may know, I provide online spiritual coaching and halachic consultation services as #theVirtualRabbi exclusively through WebYeshiva, and many of the sessions I have with clients touch on topics such as this. To find out more, and to book a free discovery call, visit https://webyeshiva.org/about-virtual-rabbi/
Parshat Hashavua

Restoring Structure and Happiness

By Rabbi Daniel Korobkin In what way is reading about the Mishkan’s inventory and construction relevant to us today? How do we gain any kind of education or inspiration from the details, especially when, in our parsha, they’re merely a repetition of the past few sections? While there are many latent messages contained within these passages, we’ll focus on the name of our parsha, Pekudei, which literally translates into “inventory items.” The word introduces a list of all the raw materials that were collected for the construction of the Mishkan. As we’ll see, this word is one of the most elastic words in the Hebrew language, having so many different meanings depending upon context. Let’s look at all the different meanings of the root of this word, which is “פקד”. The first time it’s used in the Torah, it means “to remember,” as in (Gen. 21:1) “וַיקֹוָק פָּקַד אֶת־שָׂרָה” “Hashem remembered Sarah” after years of barrenness, and blessed her with a child. The second time the word appears, in the context of the Yoseph story, it’s conjugated to mean “appoint” or “command,” as in (Gen. 39:4) “וַיַּפְקִדֵהוּ עַל־בֵּיתוֹ” – “Potiphar appointed Yoseph in charge of his household.” This is how it’s used in modern Hebrew today as well, in that a “מְפַקֵד” is a commanding officer in the IDF. When the word is conjugated in noun form, it means “assurance” or “collateral,” as in when Yoseph collected food during the years of plenty to act as an assurance (pikadon) for the years of famine (Gen. 41:36): “וְהָיָה הָאֹכֶל לְפִקָּדוֹן לָאָרֶץ לְשֶׁבַע שְׁנֵי הָרָעָב”, or when the Torah discusses a person who has a collateral item (pikadon) in his possession from a debtor (Lev. 5:21): “וְכִחֵשׁ בַּעֲמִיתוֹ בְּפִקָּדוֹן”. It also means “to compensate,” either with a reward or a punishment, as in (Ex. 20:5) “פֹּקֵד עֲוֹן אָבֹת עַל־בָּנִים” – “Hashem compensates the sin of the fathers unto the children.” It can also refer to something lost or missing, as in (Num. 31:49) “וְלֹא־נִפְקַד מִמֶּנּוּ אִישׁ:” – “No man was lost from our army.” The most common usage of the verb translates as “counting,” as in (Ex. 30:12) “כִּי תִשָּׂא אֶת־רֹאשׁ בְּנֵי־יִשְׂרָאֵל לִפְקֻדֵיהֶם” - “When you lift up the heads of the Bnei Israel for counting.” The word appears this way multiple times throughout Sefer Bamidbar. Indeed, Bamidbar has so many counts of the Jewish men of each tribe, described as “פקודים” (pekudim), that the book is also called “חומש הפקודים”, the Book of Counts (see TB Yoma 70a), or, as we commonly refer to it in English, the Book of Numbers. This seems to be how it’s used in our Parsha, Pekudei, where the Torah itemizes all the things that were donated. But how do we connect all these other meanings of “פקד”? What does “remembering” have to do with “counting,” “appointing,” or “compensating”? Plus: why are the mitzvot of Hashem called by the very same word as our Parsha (Ps. 19:9): “פִּקּוּדֵי יְקֹוָק יְשָׁרִים מְשַׂמְּחֵי־לֵב” – “The ‘pekudim’ of Hashem are upright,” and why in that verse are the mitzvot described as making the heart happy?

An objective with immediate results

Here’s a working definition of the root that will tie all the different meanings – remember, appoint, assurance, compensate, and counting – together: When the Torah wishes to describe someone focusing their attention on something or someone, with the objective of doing something productive immediately afterwards as a result of that focus, this is when the verb “פקד” is used. When it was time for Sarah to have a child, Hashem was “פקד” Sarah, meaning He focused His attention upon her for the sake of granting her a child. The Malbim explains that this is the difference between the verbs “זכר” and “פקד”: “זכר” means I haven’t forgotten you. But “פקד” means that in addition to just remembering you, my memory is causing me to take immediate action as a result of that remembrance. This is why the language that Hashem employed when announcing that He was imminently bringing the redemption from Egypt was (Ex. 3:16): “פָּקֹד פָּקַדְתִּי אֶתְכֶם” When Potiphar appointed Yoseph, or when Moshe asked for a leader to be appointed to replace him (Num. 27:16), the Torah uses the verb “פקד” to describe how they focused their attention on an individual to perform a certain task. A “פקדון” is an object that a creditor can focus upon as a source of collecting a debt in the event that the debtor defaults on the loan. When Hashem seeks to compensate a person for their deeds, He is “פוקד”, that is, He focuses His attention on their sins so that He can take the damage caused by those sins and place them upon the life of the sinner in the form of punishment. “פקד” is used when counting a person or thing with the objective of using that number for some purpose. When Hashem told Moshe in the desert to count the Jewish men over 20 years of age, it was in order to know how to organize the Jewish army that would be shortly invading Canaan. As the Malbim explains, this is the difference between the verbs “ספר” and “פקד”: They both mean to count, but “פקד” means to count for the purpose of doing something with that knowledge of how many you have. And ultimately, this is how it is used at the beginning of our parsha, to describe the inventory of all the materials donated, which was important to know in order to use those materials in the construction of the Mishkan.

Pekudim = "mitzvot"

How is this all relevant? Sometimes, Torah text has multiple meanings. Pekudei doesn’t just mean a “count,” but also “commandments,” as in the verse from Psalms, above. As the Sfas Emes writes, a deeper reading of this opening verse tells us that the pekudim, that is, the Divine commandments, are what bring about the “mishkan,” the indwelling of the Divine Presence within each and every one of us. Based on our definition, why are the Torah’s mitzvot called “pekudim”? Because they draw our attention to a particular action and spur us to make that action a part of our lives. I may instinctively sense that I should give charity, but when the Torah commands me to give charity, my attention is all the more focused on that activity. I may instinctively know that I need to unplug and take time off from the world, but the Torah commands (“פוקד”) and legislates that practice of Sabbath so that I have a greater sense of satisfaction that I’ve rested properly.

Letting Hashem into our lives

This is why King David said that the “pekudei Hashem” cause one to rejoice. We all know that there are things we would do in our lives even without a Torah. But the Torah provides us a manual, a structured set of protocols, that gives each of us the confidence and peace of mind that we’re doing something worthwhile with our lives. What greater happiness is there in life than knowing that Hashem is happy with your actions and you are living your life according to His dictates? The Midrash teaches that the reason why Bnei Israel first believed Moshe when he told them that he was sent by God was specifically because he used the term “פָּקֹד פָּקַדְתִּי֙”, “I have surely remembered you.” The Jews in Egypt had a tradition that had been passed down to them all the way from Yaakov Avinu, who passed it down to Yoseph, who further passed it down to Serach bat Asher, who was alive at the time. “Any redeemer who uses this language is authentic,” she announced. What was significant about this term? It implies that the purpose of becoming the Chosen People is so that we may assume a structured lifestyle that is the most liberating of all, a life of “pekudim.” The Kotzker used to ask: “Where is God? Anywhere you let Him in.” Let’s all bring the Mishkan, God’s Divinity, into our lives. We do that when we structure our lives with His pekudim. May we experience that joy in this new month of simcha, Adar 2, and may it usher the final Redemption, bb”a.
Parshat Hashavua