• November 9, 2026
  • 29 5787, Heshvan
  • פרשת תולדות

R. Yehuda and the Chachamim argue even when the berachot are different…?

In the previous shiur, we finished discussing the gemara in depth and with Rashi up to the mahloket between R.Ami and R.Yitzhak Nafha, about halfway down the page on Berachot 41a.  We also learned the the mishna and beginning of the gemara on Daf 44a, where the halacha of  עיקר וטפלה עמו is presented, and learned there the Rashi and Tosafot.

In this shiur, we will discuss the remaining segments of the sugya up to where we stopped reading and translating. This includes the dispute between R.Ami and R.Yitzhak Nafha,  We will need to understand the gemara’s difficulty with one of the two positions, and how it is resolved.  We will also read and discuss Rashi’s comments on these lines, and a couple of the comments of Tosafot as well.