• November 16, 2026
  • 6 5787, Kislev
  • פרשת ויצא

Menachot 91–מנחות צא

Menachot 91a and Menachot 91b,

Rabbi Gidon Rothstein leads an in-depth study session focusing on the laws of sacrificial offerings (corbanote) and their inclusion in the sukkah, with particular attention to the accompanying wine libations. The discussion engages with classical debates, notably between Ravionata and others, about interpreting Torah verses that list multiple examples of sacrifices and whether these examples imply joint or separate obligations. Rabbi Rothstein emphasizes the critical role of the Hebrew word ‘or’ in these verses, explaining that it signals separation and mandates that each sacrifice receives its own wine libation, thereby preventing the combining of libations across offerings.

The session further explores distinctions between types of commitments—personal versus animal-related—and how these affect sacrificial requirements. Specific exceptions, such as the katan and midsora sacrifices, are examined for their unique ritual rules. The age and status of sacrificial animals, especially the differentiation between male sheep (lambs versus rams) and the lack of such distinction for female sheep and goats, are clarified to understand their impact on libations and obligations.

Additional topics include the differentiation between voluntary and obligatory offerings, with voluntary ones consistently requiring wine libations, and the procedural aspects of counting animals for sacrifice, including handling counting errors. Throughout, Rabbi Rothstein underscores the Torah’s repetitive clarifications to ensure precise ritual observance. The session concludes with a summary of these principles, setting the stage for continued study in subsequent meetings.