• November 22, 2026
  • 12 5787, Kislev
  • פרשת וישלח

Chulin 116–חולין קטז

Chullin 116a and Chullin 116b,

Overview

Rabbi Gidon Rothstein leads an in-depth study session focusing on the complex halachic issues surrounding the prohibition of meat cooked with milk, known as “buston becalab.” The discussion begins with examining agricultural laws, particularly the case of Kileah Karab (mixed species planting), to understand when prohibitions take effect—whether from the moment of planting or after growth. Rabbi Rothstein clarifies that the prohibition applies once the plant takes root and grows beyond a minimal threshold, allowing extrapolation to the meat and milk prohibition.

The session then explores differing rabbinic opinions, notably those of Rabbi Akiva, on the levels of prohibition for non-domestic animals and birds. Rabbi Rothstein explains that while the prohibition is biblical for domestic animals, it may be rabbinic or not apply to birds, which lack milk. This nuanced view affects practical rulings on cooking birds with milk.

A significant portion of the meeting addresses the status of milk found in the stomachs of animals that were improperly slaughtered or are non-kosher (treif). The group discusses Rashi’s changing stance on the permissibility of using such milk for cheese production, highlighting the complexities of taste transfer and halachic concerns. They also consider the implications of animals nursing from treif animals and the resulting status of their milk, especially when purchasing animals from non-Jews.

Throughout, Rabbi Rothstein emphasizes the importance of tradition and oral transmission in maintaining halachic standards, even as new challenges arise, such as medical procedures that may render animals treif. The session concludes with reflections on balancing textual sources with communal practice to uphold Jewish dietary laws effectively.

The meeting results in a deeper understanding of the prohibitions related to meat and milk mixtures, the status of milk from various animal conditions, and the role of tradition in halachic decision-making.