• November 22, 2026
  • 12 5787, Kislev
  • פרשת וישלח

Chulin 29-חולין כט

Chullin 29a and Chullin 29b,

Overview

Rabbi Gidon Rothstein leads an in-depth halachic discussion focusing on the laws of ritual slaughter (Scheta) and related sacrificial practices. Key participants include Rabbi Rothstein and references to opinions of Rav, Rav Karjana, Rachel Luckish, and others. The meeting addresses the critical question of what constitutes a halachically valid majority when slicing the windpipe or esophagus during slaughter, with debate over whether exactly half suffices or a greater majority is required. Rabbi Rothstein clarifies that the Mishnah distinguishes between regular animals and birds versus sacrificial animals, each with different requirements for the majority cut.

The discussion further explores the significance of completing the slaughter fully, including the permissibility and value of a second person finishing the act, especially in the context of the Yom Kippur service. Timing of the slaughter act (Skita) is debated, with implications for liability and ritual purity, particularly regarding slaughtering inside or outside the Azara. The group also examines the ritual purity status of participants in the slaughter process, noting that impurity depends on whether the slaughter was valid and completed.

Finally, the meeting considers whether multiple individuals may collaborate on a single sacrificial slaughter, with differing rabbinic opinions influencing communal and individual responsibilities. Throughout, Rabbi Rothstein carefully analyzes textual sources and commentaries to elucidate these complex halachic issues, providing clarity on the distinctions between regular and sacrificial slaughter laws and their practical applications.