• November 23, 2026
  • 12 5787, Kislev
  • פרשת וישלח

Chulin 66-חולין סו

Chullin 66a and Chullin 66b,

Overview

In this session led by Rabbi Gidon Rothstein, the group delves into detailed halachic discussions on the kosher status of grasshoppers and fish, focusing on textual interpretations and practical criteria. Key participants include Rabbi Rothstein and engaged attendees such as Alba Toscano, who posed insightful questions connecting biblical narratives to the halachic topics.

The meeting begins with an analysis of rabbinic debates on which grasshopper species are permissible, emphasizing the use of general and specific terms in the Torah and classical commentaries. Rabbi Rothstein explains how differing interpretations affect the inclusion of various species based on physical characteristics like leg structure and wing coverage.

The discussion then transitions to fish kashrut laws, particularly the requirement for fins and scales. The group examines the nuances of these terms, including cases where scales may fall off, and debates the kosher status of species like tuna and swordfish. Rabbi Rothstein highlights the importance of both positive and negative commandments in the Torah, illustrating why the text explicitly states what is permitted and forbidden.

Further, the session explores the permissibility of water insects, distinguishing between those found in natural flowing waters and those in man-made containers, with references to historical beliefs about spontaneous generation. The principle of ‘klal uprat’ (general and specific terms) is applied to understand how kosher laws are derived from the text.

Rabbi Rothstein also provides practical updates about future sessions and addresses participant questions, clarifying the relationship between biblical stories and halachic principles. The meeting balances rigorous textual analysis with practical halachic implications, offering participants a comprehensive understanding of these complex topics.