• November 22, 2026
  • 12 5787, Kislev
  • פרשת וישלח

Chulin 17–חולין יז

Chullin 17a and Chullin 17b,

Overview

Rabbi Gidon Rothstein leads an in-depth study session on the Mishnah’s laws of shechita, focusing on the requirement that ritual slaughter be performed “forever” and the implications of this for Jewish practice both historically and today. Key participants include Rabbi Rothstein as the primary speaker and Alba Toscano as a participant. The session explores a foundational debate between Rabbi Akiva and Rabbi Ishmael regarding meat consumption in the desert, which informs the understanding of when and why shechita is required. Biblical verses from Deuteronomy are analyzed to clarify the legal context of meat eating and ritual slaughter, emphasizing that shechita remains obligatory even after the destruction of the Temple.

Technical aspects of shechita are examined, particularly the types of acceptable tools and the critical importance of inspecting knives for blemishes that could invalidate the slaughter. Rabbi Rothstein highlights the halachic requirement to check knives on flesh and fingernails and the respect due to Torah scholars in this process. Historical context, including the challenges of conquest and ritual purity, is discussed to situate the laws within lived Jewish experience. The session concludes with a summary and a preview of further detailed study on knife inspection, underscoring the ongoing commitment to understanding and observing these complex laws.