• November 22, 2026
  • 12 5787, Kislev
  • פרשת וישלח

Chulin 110–חולין קי

Chullin 110a and Chullin 110b,

Overview

The meeting, led by Rabbi Gidon Rothstein, delves into complex Talmudic discussions primarily focused on dietary laws, ritual observance, and judicial enforcement within Jewish law. Key participants include Rabbi Rothstein and  others. The session begins with an analysis of the prohibition against cooking milk inside a cow’s utter without tearing it open, emphasizing the Rabbis’ intent to create protective measures for community observance. Rabbi Rothstein highlights challenges posed by communal ignorance of certain laws, underscoring the necessity for clear rulings.

A significant portion of the discussion revolves around the case of Robi Bar Tomorrow, who navigates differing local customs and stringencies, raising questions about the application of personal versus communal observance standards. The role of Jewish courts in enforcing observance, especially when the Torah prescribes rewards rather than penalties, is debated, revealing nuanced views on coercion and communal responsibility. The conversation then shifts to the permissibility of consuming liver, focusing on the interaction between cooking methods and blood prohibitions, with further exploration planned for subsequent sessions.

Additionally, a participant inquires about distinctions within Midrashic literature, receiving clarification on the scope of Midrash Rabbah. A request for the source of a story about Bruria and her husband is noted, with Rabbi Rothstein committing to follow up. The meeting concludes with acknowledgments and plans for continued study, reflecting a thorough and engaged exploration of Jewish legal texts and traditions.