• November 22, 2026
  • 12 5787, Kislev
  • פרשת וישלח

Chulin 71–חולין עא

Chullin 71a and Chullin 71b,

Overview

Rabbi Gidon Rothstein leads an in-depth Talmudic study session focusing on the laws of tumah (ritual impurity) related to animals, miscarriages, and swallowed items. Key participants include Rabbi Rothstein and occasional contributions from attendees such as Bracha Schutz. The session begins with clarifying how tumah applies to various categories of animals, including kosher and non-kosher, domestic and wild, highlighting the nuanced use of terms like ‘Behama’ and ‘Kaya’ in the Torah and Gemara. Rabbi Rothstein emphasizes the Torah’s explicit naming of kosher animals and discusses the halachic implications of animals born with blemishes, such as lacking cloven hooves, which disqualify them from sacrifice.

The discussion then transitions to the ritual status of miscarried fetuses, exploring debates about when a miscarriage counts as a birth for purity laws, with references to Mishnah and Gemara opinions. A significant portion of the session is devoted to the complex topic of tumah transmission through swallowed items, introducing concepts like tumah blua and tumah beta stary, and analyzing how encapsulation affects tumah status. Rabbi Rothstein contrasts tumah susceptibility between humans and animals, noting that animals become tumah more readily in certain contexts.

The session also covers a Mishna about swallowed rings maintaining purity despite the person’s tumah status, reinforcing the encapsulation principle. Rabbi Rothstein concludes with a personal anecdote about the halachic prohibition on spaying animals, underscoring the importance of primary Torah sources in halachic decisions. Throughout, Rabbi Rothstein provides detailed textual analysis, clarifies complex halachic concepts, and addresses questions, making the session a comprehensive exploration of tumah laws related to animals and human purity.