• November 16, 2026
  • 6 5787, Kislev
  • פרשת ויצא

Menachot 77-מנחות עז

Menachot 77a and Menachot 77b,

Rabbi Gidon Rothstein leads a detailed exploration of the total offering (toda) as described in Torah law, focusing on the measurements, types of breads, and associated rituals. Key participants include Rabbi Rothstein and Bracha Schutz, with contributions from others in the discussion. The session covers the adjustment of ancient measurement units such as the ‘butt’, ‘homer’, and ‘core’, explaining their impact on the quantities required for offerings and the rationale behind limiting measure changes to a sixth to maintain market stability and prevent fraud.

The discussion delves into the types and quantities of breads accompanying the total offering, emphasizing the requirement to give one whole loaf from each type as truma to the priests, and comparing these rules to other offerings like trumat maser and the showbread. Rabbi Rothstein raises important legal questions about the consequences of misusing truma, whether deliberately or accidentally, and the penalties involved.

Comparative analysis is used to clarify ambiguous laws, highlighting similarities and differences between various offerings. The session also briefly contextualizes ancient economic expectations, noting that profit margins were historically much higher than today, which informs the understanding of legal limits on profit and measure adjustments. The meeting concludes with plans to continue the discussion in a subsequent session, focusing on further details of the total offering and related laws.